“For families living in the southwest Border country — particularly in Dumfriesshire and the old Marches — the suffering carried a different texture than it did in the crowded burghs of Edinburgh or Aberdeen. Here, survival depended almost entirely on the land itself. Crops failed. Livestock weakened. Trade slowed. Entire communities found themselves trapped between old feudal obligations, political uncertainty, and the harsh realities of subsistence living. For Border families such as the Carruthers of Holmains and their surrounding kin networks, the crisis arrived during a time when the region was already carrying centuries of instability behind it.”